The FLAMINGO project

FLAMINGO is a project of the Virgo consortium for cosmological supercomputer simulations. The acronym stands for Full-hydro Large-scale structure simulations with All-sky Mapping for the Interpretation of Next Generation Observations.


Starry flamingo

Observational cosmology based on measurements of the growth of large-scale structure is increasingly limited by the accuracy of theoretical predictions. The models that are compared with the data are nearly always based on dark matter only (DMO) simulations, though some allow for marginalization over expected baryonic effects associated with galaxy formation. However, baryonic effects become increasingly important as observations move to smaller scales, and may be considerably more complex than is assumed in the corrections applied to DMO simulations. Hydrodynamical simulations can in principle help resolve this issue, but they tend to use volumes that are too small to study large-scale structure, they often do not reproduce the relevant observables, and/or they do not include model variations that cover the relevant parameter space. The FLAMINGO project aims to address these shortcomings.

Key features:

  • Three resolutions: high/m8 (baryonic particle mass mg = 1.3 x 108 M), intermediate/m9 (mg = 1.1 x 109 M), and low/m10 (mg = 8.6 x 109 M)
  • Flagship simulations: 2.8 Gpc box size at m9 resolution (L2p8_m9) and 1 Gpc at m8 resolution (L1_m8)
  • Up to 3 x 1011 particles (2 x 50403 + 28003)
  • Subgrid feedback is calibrated to the z=0 galaxy stellar mass function and low-z cluster gas fractions using Gaussian process emulation
  • Massive neutrinos are modeled using particles with the 'δf' method that was designed to reduce shot noise
  • Twelve L1_m9 variations: eight simulations varying the calibration data and four varying the cosmology
  • Full-sky lightcone particle data and HEALPix maps for up to 8 different observer locations
  • Run with the Swift code and SPHENIX smoothed particle hydrodynamics implementation
  • 3-fluid initial conditions with separate transfer functions for CDM, baryons and neutrinos, perturbing particle masses rather than positions to suppress discreteness noise


The FLAMINGO simulations and their properties are listed below.

The first table below contain the hydrodynamical simulations in the set (Table 2 from Schaye et al. 2023). The first four lines list the simulations that use the fiducial galaxy formation model and assume the fiducial cosmology, but use different volumes and resolutions. The remaining lines list the model variations, which all use a 1 Gpc box and intermediate resolution. The columns list the simulation identifier (where m8, m9 and m10 indicate log10 of the mean baryonic particle mass and correspond to high, intermediate, and low resolution, respectively; absence of this part implies m9 resolution); the number of standard deviations by which the observed stellar masses are shifted before calibration, Δm*; the number of standard deviations by which the observed cluster gas fractions are shifted before calibration, Δfgas; the AGN feedback implementation (thermal or jets); the comoving box side length, L; the number of baryonic particles, Nb (which equals the number of CDM particles, NCDM; the number of neutrino particles, Nν; the initial mean baryonic particle mass, mg; the mean CDM particle mass, mCDM; the Plummer-equivalent comoving gravitational softening length, εcom; the maximum proper gravitational softening length, εprop; and the assumed cosmology which is specified table at the bottom of this page.

L1_m800thermal136003200031.34 x 1087.06 x 10811.22.85D3A
L1_m900thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
L1_m1000thermal1900350038.56 x 1094.52 x 101044.611.40D3A
L2p8_m900thermal2.850403280031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
fgas+2σ0+2thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
fgas-2σ0-2thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
fgas-4σ0-4thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
fgas-8σ0-8thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
M*-1σ-10thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
M*-1σ_fgas-4σ-1-4thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
Jet00jets118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
Jet_fgas-4σ0-4jets118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70D3A
Planck00thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.72 x 10922.35.70Planck
PlanckNu0p24Var00thermal118003100031.06 x 1095.67 x 10922.35.70PlanckNu0p24Var
PlanckNu0p24Fix00thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.62 x 10922.35.70PlanckNu0p24Fix
LS800thermal118003100031.07 x 1095.65 x 10922.35.70LS8

The second table contains the gravity-only FLAMINGO simulations (Table 3 from Schaye et al. 2023). Simulation L1_m9_ip_DMO is identical to L1_m9_DMO except that the phases in the initial conditions were inverted. Note that there are no hydrodynamical counterparts for L5p6_m10_DMO, PlanckNu0p12Var_DMO, L1_m9_ip_DMO and L11p2_m11_DMO.

L1_m8_DMO136003200038.40 x 10811.22.85D3A
L1_m9_DMO118003100036.72 x 10922.35.70D3A
L1_m10_DMO1900350035.38 x 101044.611.40D3A
L1p8_m9_DMO2.850403280036.72 x 10922.35.70D3A
L5p6_m10_DMO5.650403280035.38 x 101044.611.40D3A
Planck_DMO118003100036.78 x 10922.35.70Planck
PlanckNu0p12Var_DMO118003100036.74 x 10922.35.70PlanckNu0p12Var
PlanckNu0p24Var_DMO118003100036.73 x 10922.35.70PlanckNu0p24Var
PlanckNu0p24Fix_DMO118003100036.68 x 10922.35.70PlanckNu0p24Fix
LS8_DMO118003100036.72 x 10922.35.70LS8
L1_m9_ip_DMO118003100036.72 x 10922.35.70D3A
L11p2_m11_DMO11.250403280034.30 x 101189.222.80D3A

Finally, the table below lists the values of the cosmological parameters used in different simulations (Table 4 from Schaye et al. 2023). The columns list the prefix used to indicate the cosmology in the simulation name (note that for brevity the prefix 'D3A' that indicates the fiducial cosmology is omitted from the simulation identifiers); the dimensionless Hubble constant, h; the total matter density parameter, Ωm; the dark energy density parameter, ΩΛ; the baryonic matter density parameter, Ωb; the sum of the particle masses of the neutrino species, ∑ mνc2; the amplitude of the primordial matter power spectrum, As; the power-law index of the primordial matter power spectrum, ns; the amplitude of the initial power spectrum parametrized as the r.m.s. mass density fluctuation in spheres of radius 8 h-1 Mpc extrapolated to z=0 using linear theory, σ8; the amplitude of the initial power spectrum parametrized as S8 ≡ σ8m/0.3)1/2; the neutrino matter density parameter, Ων ≅ ∑ mνc2/(93.14 h2 eV). Note that the values of the Hubble and density parameters are given at z=0. The values of the parameters that are listed in the last three columns have been computed from the other parameters.

NamehΩmΩΛΩb∑ mνc2Asnsσ8S8Ων
D3A0.6810.3060.6940.04860.06 eV2.099 x 10-90.9670.8070.8151.39 x 10-3
Planck0.6730.3160.6840.04940.06 eV2.101 x 10-90.9660.8120.8331.42 x 10-3
PlanckNu0p12Var0.6730.3160.6840.04960.12 eV2.113 x 10-90.9670.8000.8212.85 x 10-3
PlanckNu0p24Var0.6620.3280.6720.05100.24 eV2.109 x 10-90.9680.7720.8075.87 x 10-3
PlanckNu0p24Fix0.6730.3160.6840.04940.24 eV2.101 x 10-90.9660.7690.7895.69 x 10-3
LS80.6820.3050.6950.04730.06 eV1.836 x 10-90.9650.7600.7661.39 x 10-3

Project references

The FLAMINGO project: cosmological hydrodynamical simulations for large-scale structure and galaxy cluster surveys (Schaye et al. 2023, accepted)

FLAMINGO: Calibrating large cosmological hydrodynamical simulations with machine learning (Kugel et al. 2023, accepted)


The FLAMINGO simulations were run on the Memory Intensive DiRAC facility managed by the Institute for Computational Cosmology, Durham University.